MSA ALTAIR io 4 vs. 4XR: A Comprehensive Guide

MSA's ALTAIR line includes two portable detectors for up to four gases: the ALTAIR io 4 and the ALTAIR 4XR. The io 4 is a cellular-connected detector that reports to the MSA Grid, MSA's cloud software. The 4XR is a standalone multigas detector. This guide compares the two using MSA's published specifications.

Ruggedness and Durability

ALTAIR io 4

  • Drop tests: More than 26 drops from 4 feet (1.2 m) under MIL-STD-810G 516.6, and an incidental 25-foot (7.5 m) drop onto concrete.
  • Dust and water: IP68 rating, which MSA states as 2 m for 1 hour.

ALTAIR 4XR

  • Drop tests: 25 drops from 4 feet (1.2 m) under MIL-STD-810G 516.6, third-party certified, and an incidental 25-foot (7.5 m) drop onto concrete.
  • Operating range: -40°F to +140°F (-40°C to +60°C).

How they compare: MSA's drop-test figures for the two detectors are nearly the same.

Sensor Performance

ALTAIR io 4

  • Sensors: MSA XCell® sensors. MSA lists a typical sensor life of 7 years for the oxygen, carbon monoxide, hydrogen sulfide and nitrogen dioxide sensors, and 5 years for the combustible sensor.
  • Gas detection: 1 to 4 gases, with sensor options that include Combustible (LEL), Oxygen, Carbon Monoxide, Hydrogen Sulfide, Methane, Sulfur Dioxide and Nitrogen Dioxide.

ALTAIR 4XR

  • Sensors: MSA XCell® sensors. MSA says they sense gas 2 times faster than the industry average.
  • Gas detection: Combustible (LEL) and Oxygen, with toxic sensor options of CO / H2S, CO (H2-Resistant) / H2S, CO / H2S-LC, CO / NO2 and SO2 / H2S-LC.

How they compare: Both detectors use XCell sensors and are available for combustible gas, oxygen, carbon monoxide and hydrogen sulfide. Beyond that, the choice depends on which gases the job requires.

Connectivity and Integration

ALTAIR io 4

  • Connectivity: CAT-M LTE cellular connectivity built in, with integration with the MSA Grid. The detector also reports location using GPS and GLONASS.
  • Deployment: MSA says it deploys in seconds, right out of the box, with no IT required.

ALTAIR 4XR

  • Connectivity: MSA's product page lists no cellular connection for the 4XR and states that Bluetooth is no longer available on it as of July 2022. Bump tests and calibration can be run on the MSA GALAXY® GX2 Automated Test System, including at a set time of day.
  • Alerts: The user-activated InstantAlert notifies others of a potentially dangerous situation. The MotionAlert option tells others that the user has become immobile.

How they compare: The ALTAIR io 4 is the one that sends readings and location over a cellular connection. The ALTAIR 4XR works as a standalone detector.

Warranty and Maintenance

ALTAIR io 4

  • Warranty: MSA lists a 4-year warranty with outright purchase. With an MSA+ subscription, MSA says the detector is covered under warranty regardless of its age, in selected locations.
  • Updates: For MSA+ subscribers, MSA says new features and functionality are pushed routinely to the Grid software and to the fleet.

ALTAIR 4XR

  • Warranty: 4-year instrument and sensor warranty.
  • Maintenance: Bump tests and calibration can be run on the MSA GALAXY® GX2 system.

How they compare: MSA lists a 4-year warranty for both detectors when purchased. The ALTAIR io 4 is also offered through the MSA+ subscription.

Applications and Use Cases

ALTAIR io 4

  • Markets: General Industry, Oil & Gas, Utilities, Fire Service, Mining, Construction.
  • Applications: Emergency Response, Turnarounds & Plant Maintenance, Confined Space.

ALTAIR 4XR

  • Markets: Utilities, Fire Service, Oil & Gas, Construction, General Industry, Mining.
  • Applications: Firefighting, Turnarounds & Plant Maintenance, Emergency Response, Welding, Confined Space.

How they compare: MSA lists the same six markets for both detectors. For the ALTAIR 4XR it also lists firefighting and welding.

Conclusion

The two detectors share XCell sensors, similar drop-test figures and a 4-year warranty when purchased. The main difference is connectivity. The ALTAIR io 4 sends gas readings and location over a cellular connection to the MSA Grid. The ALTAIR 4XR is a standalone detector with InstantAlert, optional MotionAlert and support for the GALAXY GX2 test system.

Choose the ALTAIR io 4 if your program needs gas readings and worker location reported as the work happens. Choose the ALTAIR 4XR if you need a standalone detector without a cellular connection.

Previous Post Next Post

Leave A Comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Welcome to our store
Welcome to our store
Welcome to our store